Buy Crawl Space Doors Online
Crawl Space Door Systems, Inc.
5741 Bayside Road #105
Virginia Beach, VA 23455
757-363-0005
info@crawlspacedoors.com
Mon - Fri 8a.m. - 4p.m.
Menu

NJ Judge’s Ruling – FEMA Compliant Flood Vent

FEMA Compliant Flood Vent Ruling:  What It Means to You?

For years the question “What is a FEMA Compliant Flood Vent?” has been asked.  Many people have different opinions.  FEMA Compliant flood vents can be used on homes to make the house FEMA compliant which can help reduce a homeowner’s flood insurance premiums.   “Is a flood vent FEMA Compliant?” has been asked by home owners, insurance agents, realtors, building inspectors, city code officials, different flood vent companies and many others  for a long time.  Recently a Federal Judge in New Jersey addressed the issue of what makes a flood vent “FEMA Compliant”.  The Honorable Jerome B. Simandle in his opinions wrote:

“In 1968, congress enacted the National Flood Insurance Program (hereinafter, the “NFIP”) as part of the National Flood Insurance Act, 42 U.S.C. § § 4001- 4131 (hereinafter, the “NFIA”), in order to provide previously unavailable flood insurance protection to property owners in flood-prone areas.  More specifically, the NFIA authorizes the Federal Emergency Management Agency (hereinafter, “FEMA”) “to establish and carry out a [unified and subsidized] national flood insurance program” that would allow “interested persons to purchase insurance” against any losses “arising from any flood occurring in the United States.”  42 § 4011(a).  In other words, the NFIA designated FEMA as the administrator of the NFIP Program, and vested it with the authority to develop and promulgate requirements relative to flood plain management criteria.  42 U.S.C § 4014.

As relevant here, in order to qualify for the federally-subsidized flood insurance, the NFIP regulations enacted by FEMA require, for all new construction and substantial improvements, that fully enclose areas below the lowest floor that are ….. subject to flooding …. be designed to automatically equalize hydrostatic flood forces on exterior walls by allowing for the entry and exit of floodwaters.

Flood vents, flood vent, court ruling, crawl space door systems, NJ Judge's Ruling, FEMA Compliant Flood Vent, engineered flood vent

44 C.F.R. § 60.3 (c) (5) (emphasis added).  “In other words, the regulations require that foundational spaces (or, the lower levels of dwellings) have flood vents that permit the automatic entry and exist of water.”  The “designs” for these flood vents must, in turn,

either be certified by a registered professional engineer or architect or meet or exceed the following minimum criteria:  A minimum of two openings having a total net area of not less than one square inch for every square foot of enclosed area subject to flooding shall be provided.

44 C.F.R. § 60.3 (c) (5) (emphasis added).  In that way, the relevant NFIP regulations requires, on its face, only a certification of compliance with net area requirements.”

In the past few months Judge Simandle has written opinions in two different federal cases about the FEMA Compliant flood vent issue.  The lawsuits are Smart Vent Products, Inc. v. Crawl Space Door Systems, Inc.  and Smart Vent Products, Inc. v. USA FloodAir Vents, Ltd.  You can read both of Honorable Jerome B. Simandle’s full opinions by clicking on the links.

SMART VENT - LOSES 6 YEAR LAWSUIT!

Crawl Space Door System's Engineered Flood Vents are FEMA & NFIP COMPLIANT! (Court Ruling 11/1/2017)

CLICK TO VIEW THE COURT'S RULING

September 24, 2013 Smart Vent filed a lawsuit against Crawl Space Door Systems, Inc. in the NJ Federal Court, case 1:13-cv-05691-JBS-KMW.  At the same time Crawl Space Door Systems, Inc. filed a counter-claim against Smart Vent.

CLICK TO VIEW THE LAWSUIT

Some of the jury findings (10/24/2019) are listed below.

SMART VENT (SV) Claims Against CRAWL SPACE DOORS (CSD)

1 - Did SV prove that CSD made literally false statements regarding the coverage area of CSD's Flood Vents? - NO

2 - Did SV prove that CSD made misleading statements regarding the coverage area of CSD's Flood Vents? - NO

12 - Did SV prove that CSD made literally false statements regarding the purchase and use of CSD's Flood Vents to reduce flood insurance premiums? - NO

13 - Did SV prove that CSD made misleading statements regarding the purchase and use of CSD's Flood Vents with respect to reducing flood insurance premiums? - NO

CRAWL SPACE DOORS (CSD) Counterclaims Against SMART VENT (SV)

19 - Did CSD prove that SV made literally false statements regarding the coverage area of CSD's Flood Vents? - YES

23 - Did CSD prove that SV's false and misleading statements regarding the coverage area of CSD's Flood Vents caused actual harm to CSD in terms of declining sales, loss of goodwill, etc.? - YES

24 - Did CSD prove that SV's made literally false statements that CSD's Flood Vents do not comply with FEMA and/or the NFIP? - YES

28 - Did CSD prove that SV's false and misleading statements that CSD's Flood Vents do not comply with FEMA orthe NFIP caused actual harm to CSD in terms of declining sales, loss of goodwill, etc.? - YES

CLICK TO VIEW THE VERDICT FORM - ALL OF THE JURY FINDINGS 

BELOW IS ADDITIONAL SMART VENT LAWSUIT INFORMATION:

Smart Vent vs. AAA Louvers and Millworks, Inc. - Now OUT OF BUSINESS

 Smart Vent, Inc. vs. USA Floodair Vents, LTD. - Now OUT OF BUSINESS

Smart Vent, Inc. vs. Vinylast, Inc.- Now OUT OF BUSINESS

Smart Vent, Inc. vs. American Flood Vent, Inc. - Now OUT OF BUSINESS

For additional information on the ruling, call us at 757-363-0005 or email us at info@crawlspacedoors.com

FOLLOW US

Sign Up For Email Offers!

Exclusive deals, delivered straight to your inbox.